Should have been a producer yes or no?

[troywickliff]

Do you think it was right for Rose Mcgowan not being a producer for the show even after being there for a few seasons because Holly Marie Combs and Alissa Milano we're?

[host2]

I think if she was qualified she should've been. But I dont think that the show would've even had enough money to pay for yet another producer.

[alexander]

eh I think they should've knocked off a few lists of special guests and split the money between all three since poor Rose didn't get a chance. I mean heck they should've had Alyssa just be a star and let Rose take over season 6. I wonder what it would've been like.

[troywickliff]

Yeah I guess budget is an issue and I wonder too because Rose Mcgowan is doing some guide thing on tv now with a older man.

[Omnipotent]

Why not? Maybe she would've given up some of her wealth to help produce more shows lol.

[alexander]

Yeppers! Plus when the other two didn't want to she would've totally helped out.

[Sahara Black-Density]

Wasnt it Rose that wanted to leave the show?

[phillip]

I think it was either her or Alyssa.

[Omnipotent]

I think it was Rose. I remember an interview where she was really saying she was just tired of the show and what not....Ill see if I can find it

[alexander]

eh too bad they didn't bother either 1. killing paige off or 2. get eliza to take over or 3. have a replacement for Paige or something.

[dison]

I think it would only be fair

[troywickliff]

yeah she really evolved into a great actress.

[alexander]

I know. Sigh but well she didn't get to.